Salesperson evaluation means comparing money brought in from comparable enquiries, actions taken in deals and what the salesperson did themselves. A revenue ranking mixes skill, the customer base someone inherited and help from the head of sales. Separating these lets you decide whom to train, whose workload to change and where to prepare for a replacement.

During a weekly reporting meeting at our client, which processes purchases at partner shops, our head of sales was reviewing the salespeople. The leaders were the “old hands”: previous customers and people they had referred call their old work phone. Enquiries from partners go to them too. New enquiries are distributed according to a rule, and our head of sales said of one of the weaker salespeople: “the fair lead distribution system currently gives him a chance to cope.” He receives training, support and individual reviews of his work.

Here, the revenue ranking partly reflects a phone number. If you take away new enquiries because of poor results, the salesperson will have nothing to learn from, and the comparison will become even less fair. First make the conditions equal, then check the skill.

Check your ranking: does it distinguish buyers the salesperson found from repeat orders that were already coming in? Can you see who handled the negotiations? Without this information, the surname beside an amount identifies the person responsible for the customer, but not the person who made the whole sale happen.

Evaluating a salesperson’s work

Evaluating a salesperson’s work should connect results with observable actions: how much money their deals brought in, how they guided buyers and how much of the work they did themselves. The head of sales uses this information to choose a change for a particular employee; an overall score cannot replace that decision.

First, state the work assigned to the person. A salesperson who finds new buyers and an employee who takes repeat orders are responsible for different areas. For the first, assess whether they bring in new paying customers. For the second, assess whether they retain orders from their assigned customer base and increase purchases where there is a need. A single ranking will mix these tasks before the first calculation.

Why evaluate salespeople?

To choose an action for each person: assign suitable enquiries, train them in a specific step, promote them, change their role or prepare for a replacement. After the assessment, the head of sales should understand what to review, and the salesperson should understand what to correct and by when.

Salesperson evaluation criteria: the figures

Quantitative criteria include sales plan achievement, revenue and payments, the number of deals, average order value, conversion rates, response time and repeat purchases. Look at each measure alongside the conditions in which it was achieved.

  • Sales plan achievement shows the result against the agreed target. It is misleading if people were given sales plans of different difficulty or different flows of enquiries.
  • Revenue and payments show sales volume and money received. Keep them separate: an order that has been placed may still be awaiting payment. Check large one-off payments and refunds separately.
  • Number of deals shows how many purchases were made. Without the value and contents of the orders, it is easy to mistake many small purchases for a better result.
  • Average order value is the total sales amount divided by the number of purchases over the same period. It helps you see what makes up the sales, but it can rise because of one large deal or a more expensive product.
  • Conversion rates by stage show where customers stop moving forward: after the first contact, after a proposal or before payment. Compare the same transitions; moving a record to the next stage does not in itself prove that the customer has taken action.
  • Response time shows how long the customer waited for a response. A quick greeting does not replace a substantive answer; check both the first message and whether the promised deadline was met.
  • Repeat purchases show whether assigned customers return. Allow for the usual time between orders: no purchase today does not mean the buyer has been lost.

At another of our clients, which sells through messages and a shop, our head of sales showed a task sheet organised by week. The business development director set aside the product handbook and the sales handbook: first, they needed to understand the enquiries and the salespeople’s work. For the next meeting, the task was to compile each salesperson’s sales plan, actual results and conversion rates, including transitions between stages. The figures were needed to decide what training to introduce and what to monitor. She did not yet have that understanding of the people.

The sales department’s overall conversion rate hides differences between salespeople. If one loses customers before making a proposal and another loses them after discussing terms, they need different training. Start with the point where customers are lost, then open the conversations at that stage. We will discuss the role of call numbers below the assessment table.

Qualitative criteria: what conversations and deals reveal

The quality of the work shows in actions: whether the salesperson identified the need, addressed the objection, asked for payment and did what they promised. Check this in calls, messages and deal records.

At our client, which designs and builds private houses, a salesperson said during a review that following the script had helped them handle objections. Our head of sales noted progress in identifying needs and asking clarifying questions. One message exchange showed the salesperson following the steps and the customer moving forward. The head of sales also pointed out a problem: no tasks had been set for the deals in the CRM system. The salesperson explained: “I’m trying very hard to follow the script, but because I’m still learning, communication is slow.”

A script is tested in a live conversation. A memorised text will not show whether the salesperson heard the customer’s question. Even after a good conversation, a deal can stall if nobody has set the next action.

Look for specific evidence in the review. Need — what the customer wants to buy and the criteria they use to choose. Objection — what was getting in the way and how the salesperson clarified it. Asking for payment — whether they did so once the terms were agreed. Next step — who does what and by when. Clear CRM records — whether someone can continue the work from the record if the salesperson is off sick tomorrow.

What are the main qualities of a good salesperson?

The ability to listen, understand the product, guide the customer towards a decision and keep agreements. These qualities show in actions within deals, not in how someone describes themselves at an interview. “Persistent” is not an assessment on its own: check whether the salesperson came back with the promised answer and helped the customer continue choosing.

Salesperson assessment table

Use this table for an existing team. The head of sales collects the figures and examples for it; the business owner receives the conclusion and the grounds for a decision.

What we assessWhat information is neededHow it affects the decision
Financial resultPayments and refunds for assigned deals; large one-off payments shown separatelyShows which sales make up the employee’s total
Conversion rateThe number of buyers and enquiries in the same group, given the same amount of time to buyLets you look for differences in how similar demand is handled
Sales termsDiscounts, deferred payments and agreed exceptionsShows what it took to achieve the result and who approved concessions
Work on customer needsThe conversation makes clear what the buyer is choosing, on what terms and what is preventing a decisionLets you identify a specific skill to develop
Keeping agreementsThe step promised to the customer, the deadline and the action actually takenDistinguishes a negotiation error from an unfulfilled promise
IndependenceWhat the salesperson decided and what the head of sales did for themShows what work the employee can be trusted to do without constant help
Response to trainingOne reviewed mistake and actions in subsequent similar dealsProvides grounds to continue training or change the decision about the person

The number of calls shows whether there were enough attempts to contact buyers, but does not determine the employee’s standing in the table. Complete CRM records do not make up for an unfulfilled promise to a customer either.

Do not reduce the table to an arithmetic average. High revenue does not cancel out an unapproved discount, and accurate records do not cancel out a lack of buyers. Each discrepancy requires its own decision.

First, make salespeople comparable

Compare employees working on the same tasks: new enquiries with new enquiries, repeat orders with repeat orders, one product with the same product. Then account for the source of demand, the time since the enquiry and the amount of work assigned.

Choose one completed period in which enquiries came in. For each salesperson, record the number of enquiries received, the number of purchases and the total payments from that specific group as of the same date. If customers take several months to buy, yesterday’s enquiries are no basis for judging sales ability. First compare the progress of deals that have had the same time to develop; record the financial total after the observation period used by the company.

For example, with similar incoming enquiries, the first salesperson received 40 enquiries and had 12 buyers, while the second received 90 enquiries and had 18 buyers. The first salesperson’s conversion rate: 12 / 40 × 100% = 30%. The second’s: 18 / 90 × 100% = 20%. With the same payment of 100 thousand roubles per purchase, the totals will be 1.2 and 1.8 million roubles.

The second is ahead in money. The first is ahead in the proportion of enquiries that became buyers. The calculation does not pick a winner: it gives you a precise question about why a larger number of enquiries produced a lower proportion of purchases. This difference requires a review of workload and actions. Automatically giving the second salesperson even more enquiries based on revenue means increasing their workload before finding the cause.

Repeat the calculation using your own data and compare the conversion rate with the number of deals active at the same time. Separate repeat orders. Otherwise, the arithmetic will be accurate, but the conclusion about the person will be arbitrary.

Keep enquiries the salesperson deemed unsuitable in the original total and show them on a separate line with the reasons. Otherwise, the employee can improve their conversion rate by removing difficult enquiries from the calculation. Calculate conversion for suitable enquiries as an additional measure only when the same selection criteria apply to the whole team.

A small sample requires particular care. For example, one purchase out of five is 20%, and two out of five is 40%. The twofold difference came from one customer’s decision. A staffing decision requires the result to be repeated across subsequent comparable groups, along with evidence of the work; there is no single number of enquiries that is enough for every sales department.

Whose work is credited to the salesperson

Independence shows in decisions within a deal: who established the purchase terms, suggested a way to continue negotiations and saw the agreement through. Getting an exception approved by the head of sales does not in itself mean the salesperson is weak.

If the salesperson gathered the customer’s requirements, calculated the options and brought a proposal within their responsibilities, they did the work. If they forwarded the buyer’s message, after which the head of sales identified the need, chose the proposal and arranged the next conversation, the result includes a substantial contribution from the head of sales. These forms of help need to be distinguished.

Do not deduct an arbitrary percentage from revenue “for the head of sales’ involvement”. The money remains the company’s money. Alongside the result, simply record the step at which the head of sales became involved and exactly what they did. This makes clear which skill the employee needs to develop and how much attention an additional workload will require.

For an initial review, the head of sales could take, for example, two paid deals, two lost deals and one unfinished deal for each salesperson. For any step in question, you need the customer’s message, the salesperson’s action and what happened next. If you find a recurring mistake, extend the review to other deals with the same difficulty.

The business owner’s presence in negotiations should also be taken into account. If employees bypass the head of sales and get a decision directly from the owner, the assessment of independence will depend on whom the owner helped more often. The route a difficult question takes is covered separately: who they will go to with a difficult deal after a head of sales is appointed.

How do you conduct an assessment and make a decision about an employee?

Conduct the assessment in four stages: agree on the task and criteria, collect comparable information, discuss discrepancies with the salesperson, then assign an action with a deadline and a way to judge the result. The business owner needs a conclusion for each employee, while the head of sales handles the preparation and conversations.

Before the conversation: prepare the evidence

For the first assessment, record the rules before making calculations. Specify the salesperson’s role, the period, customer groups, sources of money and deals, and permitted commercial terms. Keep the pay rules already announced in force: an assessment table must not retrospectively change a bonus already earned.

The final record for each person needs six fields: assigned work, result, conditions for receiving customers, specific difficulty, help provided and proposed decision. Links to deals and extracts from conversations remain in an appendix for the head of sales. This amount of information lets the business owner make a decision without listening to every call themselves.

Give the salesperson an opportunity to correct a factual error. Was the order handed to them just before payment? Was the required product unavailable? Did the head of sales approve the discount? This information changes the conclusion. The employee does not have to agree with the assessment, but a confirmed circumstance cannot be dismissed simply because it gets in the way of a convenient explanation.

After the conversation: choose one change

“Improve sales” does not define the work. If buyers leave after discussing the price, establish what is happening: the salesperson does not find out what the buyer is comparing it with, promises an unavailable discount or fails to return with an agreed answer. Each of these actions needs its own correction.

What has been establishedDecisionHow to judge the result
The salesperson loses buyers over the same recurring questionReview this step and practise the response using their dealsTakes the required action in new conversations without prompting
Results worsened as the number of active deals increasedLimit the workload and resolve delays in serving customersMeets promised deadlines; conversion rates for similar groups are then compared
Handles repeat orders but conducts new negotiations only with helpConsider a separate role working with the existing customer base, if the company needs oneRetains orders from the customer base without the head of sales’ constant involvement
The salesperson requests information they cannot access, but receives no answer in timeFix the transfer of information from the department responsibleReceives the answer on time and passes it on to the buyer
The requirement is clear, resources are available, and the mistake recurs after reviewPrepare a decision on replacing them and handing over their customersEvidence has been collected from several instances; each customer has been assigned to the next person responsible

Choose the time allowed for the action according to what is being assessed. For example, you can allow ten working days to correct the way someone responds and observe it in new conversations. To draw a conclusion about payments, allow enough time for the relevant deals to finish. Set both dates in advance: training must not turn into endless waiting, and a long sales process must not become grounds for blaming someone for a lack of money on the third day.

Check whether the head of sales has enough time to help and whether the employee has enough suitable enquiries to practise on. A deadline on its own will not teach anyone anything. Learning about the product is covered separately: when a busy new salesperson will start selling.

How do you collect data for an assessment?

The assessment is based on deals and payments in CRM, call recordings and messages. These let you reconstruct what the customer asked, what the salesperson did and how the conversation ended.

First, check the records: whether people responsible have been assigned, whether payments match orders and whether any enquiries have been lost. Then connect the deal record with the conversation. A “declined” status without a reason does not explain the salesperson’s work, and a good response without further action does not prove a result.

Other methods answer narrower questions:

  • Customer feedback helps you find an instance to check. Compare the complaint with the agreement and the employee’s actions.
  • A mystery shopper shows how a particular enquiry is handled. One contact cannot tell you about the person’s entire work.
  • A product knowledge test reveals gaps in knowledge. Check the ability to apply an answer in a conversation with a buyer.
  • Self-assessment, “360” assessment and the head of sales’ impression show how the person and those around them perceive their work. Ask for examples: which deal does the opinion relate to?

A decision about a person must be based on records and deals. Opinions provide questions for discussion. Otherwise, a loud complaint or confident speech at a sales meeting will outweigh months of work.

Salesperson evaluation checklist

The checklist examines results, deals, conversations and independence. The head of sales supports each answer with a record from the accounts or a conversation.

Results from comparable enquiries — how to compare salespeople:

  • Are we comparing the same tasks and sources of enquiries?
  • Have these enquiries had time to complete the buying cycle?
  • What explains the difference in payments and conversion rates?

Deals — what to check in the work:

  • Are the next action, the person responsible and the deadline clear?
  • Has the promise to the customer been kept?
  • Can someone pick up the deal using the record?

Conversation — which actions to look for in the dialogue:

  • Did the salesperson identify the need and the reason for the objection?
  • Did they ask for payment after agreeing on the terms?
  • Who is guiding the conversation towards a decision?

Independence and response to review — how to account for help from the head of sales:

  • What did the salesperson do themselves, and what did the head of sales decide for them?
  • Did they apply the technique discussed in the next similar deal?

Today, ask the head of sales to complete this checklist for one employee. For the confirmed problem, choose an action from the decision table and set a review date. There is no need to add up the “yes” answers.

How often should you evaluate salespeople?

Review deals and conversations weekly, and money when the chosen group of enquiries has completed the buying cycle. Revisit the decision about the employee at the deadline set in advance in the plan for changes.

Check a new salesperson more often, using their next conversations: in the first weeks, their enquiries may not yet have brought in money, but their actions are already visible. Did they clarify the need, return with an answer and set the next step? It is better to check the correction in the next similar conversation, before the mistake is repeated with all the customers waiting.

A weekly review does not require you to fill in the whole assessment table again. Return to the action you agreed to correct; choose the decision using the table above.

How do you evaluate a new salesperson, including an experienced one?

Evaluate a new salesperson against their assigned work: for incoming enquiries, look at actions and the progress of enquiries; for an existing customer base, look at changes in orders and customer activity. Experience and the cost of hiring do not replace this check.

At the first meeting, the owner of a wholesale company described hiring an expensive salesperson whom they expected to perform well. There was already a base of regular buyers: some placed orders themselves, while others needed regular contact. According to the owner, sales fell during the salesperson’s time there, and they parted ways. Customer and order data were in the system, but the owner had no time to examine them in detail.

This does not yet prove that the salesperson alone caused the decline. But without reviewing the customer base, you cannot understand exactly what changed. I would start with the assigned customers: who bought before, when they usually placed a repeat order, whom the new employee contacted and what happened next.

Compare the same customer base before and after the handover, allowing for the season, product availability and changes in terms. Show orders that came in on their own separately from work to bring buyers back. You can then discuss a specific missed contact or lost order. The candidate’s reputation was already discussed at the interview.

What mistakes are made when evaluating salespeople?

The main mistake is to treat the final amount or an impression of the person as an explanation of their work. An assessment should connect the result with conditions, actions and a subsequent check.

  • Ranking when enquiries are distributed unevenly. Return to the old work phone number in the introduction and the rules for comparability: who receives orders that are already coming in?
  • An average score instead of a decision. Different rows in the assessment table require different actions. Averaging can hide an unfulfilled promise behind high revenue.
  • An impression without records. A confident presentation at a sales meeting does not show how someone talks to a buyer. Open the conversation.
  • No right to correct a fact. Before making a decision, let the employee check the evidence: the process is described in the preparation for the conversation.
  • A one-off assessment. Without another check, it is unclear whether training helped. Set the next review date straight away.
  • Recalculating an earned bonus retrospectively. A new assessment helps change future work; keep the pay rules already announced.

How does evaluating a salesperson differ from evaluating a sales department?

Evaluating a salesperson shows how the person performs their task. Evaluating a department covers the flow of enquiries, the sales funnel, people’s workloads and the work of the head of sales: the conditions the company creates for sales.

How do you evaluate a sales department’s effectiveness?

Compare incoming enquiries, progress through the sales funnel and payments with the team’s workload. Check where customers are lost and which cause the head of sales needs to address.

If everyone faces delays at the same approval step, first check who should respond to the department and when. If, under the same conditions, one salesperson regularly misses the next contact, review their actions. A revenue table cannot distinguish these causes.

Before replacing someone, make sure they received a clear task, suitable enquiries and the authority to make the necessary decisions. Otherwise, the next employee will get stuck at the same point.

When there are not enough facts to make a decision about a person

If the report contains only a total amount, the link between money, deals and the salesperson’s actions is missing from the decision. The head of sales brings this together in the records or uses a tool to analyse the data.

RENTROP has AI ROP for this task — a service that increases sales by 20–30 % from day one: sales team assessment shows financial results and conversion rates for each salesperson. It analyses calls and messages alongside the deal record and prepares an employee assessment for a one-to-one conversation.

An assessment is especially revealing when the revenue leader continues with the same work while another salesperson is given a larger number of suitable enquiries. The first still ranks higher in the overall table. But now the company knows what it is buying through additional pay, training or a new vacancy: the ability to perform specific work under known conditions. A place in the ranking does not provide that answer.