“I need someone to do this.”

The head of sales starts work. At the first meeting, the owner tells the team: from now on, take all questions to them. Two days later, a salesperson messages the owner directly: an important client is asking for a discount, and an answer is needed now. The owner knows the background and replies. They cannot afford to lose the deal.

The issue is resolved. At the same time, the team has learnt who is still the real head of sales here.

I would not start by concluding that the new head of sales is weak. First, I would retrace this episode step by step. Not who was appointed to lead, but whose decision changed what the salesperson did.

One quick answer brings back the old way of working

Before hiring a head of sales, the owner personally handled complex deals, approved discounts, corrected salespeople and kept agreements with important clients in their head. This was not a mistake. This was how the department worked.

But a role can be handed over by a formal order; the usual route a work question takes cannot.

A salesperson goes where they will get a final answer fastest. The owner replies because they really do understand the situation better than the new person. The head of sales learns about the decision afterwards. Next time, the salesperson takes the short route again.

Everyone acts reasonably. The result is unreasonable: the head of sales is responsible for the department but does not control the decisions that shape its work.

Here is how this shows up:

  • the salesperson explains the difficulty to the owner before explaining it to the head of sales;
  • a task for a deal is changed without the head of sales being involved;
  • after the review, no one comes back to check what the salesperson did;
  • two different answers remain in force, and the team chooses the one that suits them;
  • the head of sales receives a decision that has already been made — to document it, communicate it and check that it is carried out.

This is not “poor delegation” in general. The issue is much narrower: the new person already holds the role, but the right to decide the next step in daily work remains with the previous leader.

Check the decision process, not the person's character

The phrase “the head of sales is not up to the job” explains nothing. Different failures may lie behind it.

A deal has stalled. The head of sales did not ask for the missing facts and took the problem to someone higher up — they have not done their job.

The head of sales asked for the facts and told the salesperson what to do, but the owner gave the salesperson a different instruction directly — the head of sales' work has been cancelled out within the company.

The head of sales assigned a task, the salesperson did not complete it, and there was no follow-up check — the department has a decision, but no check that it is carried out.

From the outside, all three situations look the same: an important deal is back with the owner. But replacing the person, defining who can make which decisions and setting up task checks are three different actions. If you mix them up, you can hire a second strong candidate and get the same result.

So I would take the most recent disputed episode, rather than an assessment of the head of sales:

  1. What fact was unknown at the start?
  2. Who asked for it?
  3. Who chose the next action?
  4. Who assigned the task to the salesperson?
  5. Who could overturn that decision?
  6. Who came back and checked the result?

If the head of sales only reports back in this chain, they are not the one in charge yet. If they control the chain but do not take it through to the next check, then there is something specific to discuss about the quality of their work.

“I cannot hand everything over to a new person straight away”

It is a fair question. Two different jobs are being mixed together here.

Handing prices, the budget and decisions that put the whole business at risk to someone you do not know is one thing. Handing over daily work with deals and salespeople within boundaries agreed in advance is another.

No one is asking for the first. Without the second, you cannot assess the head of sales.

For a week, a limited part of the work is enough: a few stalled deals and one recurring mistake by the team. Agree straight away:

  • what the head of sales decides independently;
  • what fact they must bring to the owner;
  • which decision remains solely with the owner;
  • when the head of sales checks that the salesperson has done the task.

Pricing, strategy, the budget, production constraints and the employer's staffing decisions remain with the owner. A question for the client, the next step in a deal, a task for a salesperson and returning to that task belong to the head of sales.

The boundary is not there for freedom's sake. It is there so you can identify who produced the result and analyse a mistake.

The practical test starts when something does not go as planned

At an interview, it is easy to work through a tidy situation. In the department, facts are missing, a salesperson argues, a client asks for an exception, a task has not been done. This is where the head of sales' work becomes visible.

Not through a promise to increase sales in a week. Through what happens between the first task and the follow-up check.

After a week, you can see:

  • salespeople take work questions to the head of sales first;
  • a stalled deal has a confirmed next step;
  • the task is specific, rather than “push the client to agree”;
  • the head of sales came back at the deadline and saw whether the task had been done;
  • if an action did not work, they changed it on the basis of a new fact;
  • the owner received a prepared decision, not the whole problem.

“Work with the client” cannot be checked. “By Thursday, find out who is involved in the choice and agree a date for the next conversation” can. There is a person, an action, a deadline and a record for the head of sales to return to.

If these signs are missing, do not rush to defend either the head of sales or the owner with general statements. Separate the causes again. Is the head of sales failing to make a decision? Unable to turn a review into a task? Failing to check that it is done? Or is their decision being overturned before it has a chance to work?

Why a new search often takes you back to the same point

A strong candidate does not change how the company is set up.

The second head of sales will also start work, look at the CRM system, hold meetings and assign the first tasks to the team. Then an important deal will come along. The salesperson will again message the person whose word is final. If the owner replies without involving the head of sales, the new head of sales will get the same role: to stand alongside other people's decisions and answer for the overall result.

So the obvious solution, “we will find someone stronger”, does not work until you have checked where work questions go. It may turn out that the person really does need replacing. But that should be clear from their actions, not from a role they were never allowed to perform.

Where RENTROP fits in

At RENTROP, the outsourced head of sales service is daily sales management, not providing the owner with another head of sales.

The head of sales manages daily work with salespeople and deals. The business development director checks the quality of their decisions: what facts they are based on, whether a specific task has been assigned, whether the head of sales came back to check that it was done and what they changed after things went off track. AI helps find stalled deals, missed steps and recurring mistakes in the data and communications. A person makes the final decision.

If the head of sales changes, the figures, decisions and agreements gathered so far stay within the project, and the work does not start from scratch. Strategy, prices, the budget and decisions affecting the business as a whole remain with the owner.

Before making another overall assessment of the head of sales, retrace one difficult deal from the question to the follow-up check. That will show who you hired — a leader or someone who reports back.

A head of sales is assessed not by the fact that they have been put in charge of the department, but by the decisions the department has actually left to them.