Start with lost deals: sales call evaluation based on random recordings can reward politeness and miss the conversation after which the customer left. While the head of sales counts completed items in the script, the salesperson repeats the mistake on the next call.

Your salesperson sent the customer an estimate. During the conversation, they introduced themselves, explained the terms and said goodbye — there seems to be nothing to fault. Yet why the customer needed the estimate, who they were discussing it with and when they would return with a decision remained unclear. The deal record says “awaiting a response”. Both are waiting. The next conversation is not scheduled in the calendar.

Adding a few more items to the checklist is easy. It is harder to answer this: who opened this deal, found the missed question and taught the salesperson to ask it?

Sales call evaluation: what should it show?

You need to identify the salesperson’s action that helped the customer move towards a purchase or left them without an answer. To do this, listen to the recording and compare it with the deal history: what the customer has already said, what they were promised and what was done after the conversation.

The number of calls shows the workload. Their duration suggests where to look more closely. Neither measure on its own explains why the customer did not buy: a short conversation may have ended in payment, a long one in a discussion of terms the company does not meet.

Here it is important to separate three things: the quality of the salesperson’s actions, the outcome of a particular conversation and the outcome of the deal. The salesperson may have clarified everything and replied on time, while the customer needs a product that is not available. Teaching that salesperson to sound more cheerful when saying hello is pointless. You need to discuss the product range and the terms for handling such requests.

Monitoring salespeople’s calls: which recordings should you open first?

Open deals that have stalled or ended in rejection, and find the conversation before that happened. To find where sales are lost, this is more useful than choosing recordings just because they were the first ones you came across in the phone system.

If the customer went silent after the estimate, listen to the discussion of the estimate. If they declined after the timing was agreed, listen to the conversation about timing. A “too expensive” note in the CRM system does not prove anything yet: the salesperson may have recorded their own explanation while the customer was asking about something else entirely.

Keep the deal record and correspondence to hand. The right question may have been asked earlier. A document sent after the call may have resolved the concern. Evaluating a single audio file will not reveal this.

Separate initial incoming calls, cold calls, repeat sales and service conversations. A first introduction and a call about delivery have different purposes. Add successful deals of the same type: these can show you an approach to the conversation that works. To assess an employee overall, you need a separate sample with different outcomes; otherwise you will have collected only their mistakes from the start.

Sales call evaluation criteria: what really matters?

Check four decisions: did the salesperson understand the customer’s task, work through the obstacle, agree what happens next and suggest payment when the customer was ready for it? For each item, look for evidence in what was said, rather than an impression that they “sounded confident”.

Understanding the task means being able to explain what the buyer intends to do and which conditions matter to them. Check the presentation here too: does the proposed solution address that task, or did the salesperson simply list the product’s features? For equipment, operating conditions may matter; for a service, the launch date. Your product determines the specific questions.

Working through the obstacle means finding out exactly what stands in the way, giving a relevant answer and checking whether the question remains. You can give a long speech in response to “too expensive”. If the customer is still comparing different configurations, the objection has not been addressed.

Agreeing what happens next means both sides understand who does what and by when. Suggesting payment means you have not left a buyer who is ready to buy with just a price list. At an early stage, an estimate, a meeting or an agreement on technical requirements is more appropriate than payment.

Greetings, clear speech and respectful communication matter too. But a flawless introduction does not make up for promising an impossible deadline or ignoring a question. The head of sales reviews these incidents separately from the overall evaluation.

Sales call evaluation checklist: how do you fill it in without guessing?

Create a short table with evidence for each item. Before the table, state the salesperson, date, links to the recording and deal, the type of conversation and its purpose, so you can return to the same incident a week later.

What to checkWhat should be heard or seenWhat to record
Task and offerThe salesperson clarified the customer’s requirements and linked the offer to themThe words used and the timestamp in the recording
Obstacle to purchaseIdentified the reason for doubt, answered and checked the reactionWhat stood in the way and what answer the customer received
Next stepsAn action, the person responsible and a deadline have been agreedThe agreement and the task in CRM
PaymentA specific way to buy was offered when the customer was readyThe offer and the buyer’s response

For example, in a conversation with your salesperson, the customer asks for an estimate to get approval from the technical director. The salesperson promises to send it today and says goodbye. Under “next steps”, write: sending the estimate has been agreed; discussing the outcome has not. The task for the salesperson is to clarify when the estimate will be reviewed and what the technical director will need to decide. This is something you can practise.

If there were no objections, that item does not apply. If the recording cut off, there is not enough information to draw a conclusion. These notes are different from a salesperson’s mistake. And they do not remove the need to check the deal record: the promised document may never have been sent.

Sales call quality evaluation: how do you score it?

To begin with, marking items as “done”, “partly done” and “not done”, with an explanation, is enough. If you need an overall measure, convert them into 2, 1 and 0 points respectively, and exclude items that do not apply.

The formula is simple: divide the points scored by the maximum possible for the applicable items and multiply by 100%. For example, across four items, the salesperson received 2, 1, 1 and 0. The total is 4 out of a possible 8, or 50%. This is the proportion of the chosen rules followed, not the probability of a sale.

Weighting is needed when a company deliberately considers one item more important than another: multiply the score by its weight and calculate the maximum using the same weights. I would start without this complication. If nobody can explain what action counts as “partly done”, the weighting will only make the argument look like a precise calculation.

Keep the failed item next to the overall score. Otherwise, the salesperson will improve their greeting, the average score will rise, and the customer will still leave without an agreement. Mark rudeness, inaccurate information about terms and promises that cannot be kept separately: good scores for the rest of the conversation must not hide them.

How many calls should you listen to so there is time for feedback?

Set aside time in the calendar for both the recordings and the conversation with the employee. The five most recent lost deals are a starting point for diagnosis, not enough evidence to rank the whole team.

For example, you take ten recordings and allow ten minutes for each one, including the deal record. That is a hundred minutes before the meetings with salespeople. If you have less free time, reduce the first batch, but follow it through to correcting the mistakes. A folder of a hundred calls you have listened to without feedback does not help the sales team.

I would review recent stalled deals during the working week, while it is still clear what was happening with the customer. After practice, I would return to the same skill a week later. If there had been no comparable conversations during that time, I would postpone the check until there were, rather than claim improvement based on a different type of call.

Sales call quality checks: who is responsible for change?

The head of sales is responsible for changing how the salesperson works, even if another employee or a program adds notes to the recordings. The business owner checks that the head of sales has followed through from the mistake found to a follow-up check.

Before you start evaluating, show the salespeople the criteria and review one conversation together. If two reviewers give different marks, clarify the rule using the specific incident. If an employee disputes a mark, look at the original recording and earlier correspondence: the required action may have happened earlier. A corrected evaluation is more useful than an argument about who is in charge.

While the rules are being interpreted differently, I would not link scores to bonuses. First, make sure everyone understands the actions in the same way. When the product, terms or stages of the sale change, review the checklist and note the date of the new version. How to word requirements that can be met is covered in the article “Sales standards: how to write workable rules”.

How do you review a mistake so the salesperson speaks differently tomorrow?

Choose one mistake and discuss it with the salesperson one to one until you have a specific alternative. General advice to “get better at closing the sale” leaves them with exactly the same words.

Let us return to the estimate at the start of the article. First, ask the salesperson to explain what decision they were expecting from the customer. Then play the end of the recording: did they manage to agree when that decision would be discussed? Let the salesperson come up with a question they should have asked and say it aloud. The head of sales will play the customer, who does not know the date yet.

Find a successful moment from the salesperson’s own work too: it is easier to build on than someone else’s perfect conversation. In the review notes, write down one action and a date to check it. If the same gap exists across the whole team, check the script and training: perhaps this was simply never taught. The collected evaluations then point to the work of the head of sales.

How can you tell whether reviews help salespeople sell?

A week later, check whether the required action appears in new conversations of the same type and whether promises to customers have been kept. A rise in the average score without this tells you little.

For example, you agreed to clarify how the estimate would be approved. In new deals, it should be clear who is reviewing it, what they need to decide and when there will be an answer. Alongside this, look at progress to the next stage and payments, but do not attribute every change to training: the enquiries, product availability or terms may have changed.

You can compare salespeople when customer types and stages are comparable and the evaluation rules are the same. It is more useful to start by comparing an employee with their own previous work. The head of sales’ daily work on deals is covered separately: “Monitoring salespeople’s work: what to check every day”.

When should you add automated analysis?

Automation is worth adding when manual review leaves too many conversations unchecked. First, check that recordings are available, linked to deals and make it clear who spoke to whom. Without a recording, there is nothing to base an evaluation on.

A manual review lets you look closely at a difficult incident, but takes time. Self-assessment prepares the salesperson for a meeting, but needs to be checked with the head of sales. Automated analysis helps handle the volume; questionable quotes and conclusions still need to be checked against the original conversation. Start with a small batch and compare the system’s conclusions with a manual review using your rules.

RENTROP has AI ROP, a service for increasing sales by 20–30 % from day one. When the head of sales does not have enough time to prepare an analysis of salespeople’s calls, it shows failures with a quote and a suggested response, prepares a review of each salesperson for a one to one meeting, and analyses calls and correspondence alongside the deal record. This is more than speech analytics.

What should the business owner check today?

Open the five most recent lost deals and ask the head of sales to show you three things for each: who listened to the conversations, which mistake was discussed with the salesperson and where the correction was checked.

If nobody listened, assign a review. If you found a cause outside the salesperson’s work, address the terms, product or timing. If you found a mistake but did not show it to the salesperson, a one to one meeting is needed. If you discussed it but did not check it, open new conversations after the training.

Close the first gap you find. Another column of scores can wait.