“They’re generally capable, but something isn’t working.” When sales fall, the next step seems clear: hire one more salesperson. More people mean more conversations, deals and money.
First, I would check something else: is the team really short of people — or is it losing what it already gets?
Open ten deals in your CRM system: five that a strong salesperson is moving forward, and five that have stalled. For each, reconstruct the last conversation. What did the customer confirm? What next step was set? Who set it? Where did the salesperson decide for themselves, and where did they wait for the head of sales or the owner?
If successful deals follow the same clear path, salespeople have time to follow it, and new enquiries really are waiting for someone to handle them, hiring will increase capacity. If the deal records say “thinking it over”, there is no date for the next contact, everyone sells in their own way, and difficult questions go to the owner, the team may be short of people. But that has not yet been proved.
First, something else is clear: the team does not know how to repeat one way of selling that works.
A new hire learns from the decisions accepted every day
Documents can set out the right stages, questions and discount rules. A new hire will still learn faster from the consequences of real actions than from documents.
If a proposal is sent without arranging the next conversation and the deal stays in the forecast, they understand: “call later” counts as a normal step. If an overdue task is rescheduled before the sales meeting and the head of sales does not revisit why it was overdue, a tidy report matters more than moving the deal forward. If a salesperson asks for a discount at the first “too expensive” and nobody reviews the conversation, a discount becomes the first way to negotiate. If the owner takes over every difficult deal, the new hire learns to wait for someone higher up to rescue them.
No one has to say these rules aloud. It is enough to let those actions continue.
So a new employee’s questions in the first week are not an obstacle to settling in, but a test of the team. Where is the up-to-date presentation? What next step counts as normal? What should be in the forecast? Who decides on a discount? If the head of sales and two salespeople give different answers to one question, the problem at this point is not the new hire’s memory. The company itself has not chosen which action it wants them to repeat.
A strong salesperson can show a technique. The head of sales must make it repeatable
Usually, a new hire is seated next to the best salesperson. This makes sense: a real conversation is more useful than one more presentation.
But observing and teaching are two different jobs. A new hire hears a phrase that works, but may not see what facts the salesperson gathered before saying it, why they asked the question at that moment, or what told them they could discuss the price. They copy the words. They do not copy the reasoning behind the decision, because nobody has put it into words.
After a joint call, the head of sales needs to review one specific moment: what we learnt about what the customer is trying to achieve, what risk we noticed, why we chose this next step, and what the salesperson should try in a new conversation. The next deal tests whether they can apply it: did the person spot the same signal themselves and change their action — or did they just repeat the phrase again?
That is where “sit next to them for a while” ends and management begins.
Before posting a vacancy, distinguish a shortage of people from a lack of management
The statement “I need someone to take care of this” is fair. It just combines two different tasks.
The first is to add someone to do the work in an area that already functions: handle incoming enquiries, bring back past customers, find new ones in the chosen segment. For this, you need to show where the work comes from, where the task starts and ends, which decisions are allowed, and what shows that a step is complete.
The second is to decide how the team should work in the first place: who to sell to, what counts as a good deal, who reviews conversations, and what to do when something goes off track. This is the head of sales’ job. If it is quietly added to a salesperson’s vacancy, the company is looking for a salesperson while also expecting them to build a system.
A capable person really can bring their own way of organising work. But then you need to be honest: the team depends on the new employee’s personal way of working, rather than an agreed way of working. When they leave, one more version of sales will begin.
You do not need a perfect system before hiring. You need one area of work that can already be checked. For example: a salesperson receives an incoming enquiry, finds out what the customer is trying to achieve, agrees on the next contact and records it in the CRM. The head of sales spots a missed step within the same work cycle, reviews the conversation and sends the salesperson back to the deal.
Not twenty stages. One path that the head of sales can show, check and correct.
After a week, you can see the quality of training. After a month, you have grounds to judge the person
In the first week, it is too early to demand revenue. But you can already open the new hire’s real deals and check four things:
- whether each active deal records what the customer confirmed and what will happen next;
- whether the employee understands which decisions they make themselves and which they take to the head of sales or the owner;
- whether the head of sales has reviewed at least one real conversation and set a different action;
- whether the company has resolved the contradiction revealed by the new hire’s question, or simply given them one more verbal answer.
If these signs are there, the person has not just “completed their induction” — they have started working in a way that can be observed. If not, you first need to find out who has not done their part: the new hire, the head of sales, or the company itself, which did not provide one answer.
After a month, the check changes. Take the deals after feedback and see whether the repeated action has changed. Does the salesperson set a confirmed next step themselves? Do they avoid hiding agreements in private messages? Do they avoid asking for a discount before understanding the reason for the refusal? Does the head of sales spot when the salesperson goes off track before the owner does and get them back to work?
If the requirement was specific, the head of sales demonstrated it in a conversation, checked whether it was repeated and gave feedback, but the action still did not change, there are grounds to assess the candidate’s skill or suitability. If nobody stated the requirement or checked that it was carried out, the conclusion “we hired a weak salesperson again” is not yet based on fact.
This is not an attempt to make excuses for every employee. It is the boundary between two decisions: replace the person, or start managing them first.
Where RENTROP fits
This is exactly why, in our “turnkey sales management” model, we do not start with the number of vacancies.
The head of sales manages salespeople and deals every day: setting tasks, reviewing conversations, checking the next step and changing the action if a deal stalls. The business development director checks the head of sales’ work: whether they spotted a recurring mistake in time and whether the team’s behaviour changed after the review. AI helps find stalled deals, missed steps and recurring mistakes in data and communications.
Strategy, prices, the marketing budget and the employer’s staffing decisions remain with the owner. RENTROP is responsible for daily sales management within the agreed scope of work.
Before posting a vacancy, check ten real deals rather than the profile of the ideal candidate. They will show what the new person will get from the team: a way of selling that works, or a set of habits that nobody checks.
If the team cannot show a new hire how to move a deal forward without giving discounts out of habit, without “call later” and without the owner coming to the rescue, a new salesperson will not add capacity. They will add one more version of sales.