A 12-point interview form helps you find out how a candidate planned the sales team’s work, changed what salespeople did and spotted delays in deals. Head of sales interview questions should focus on decisions they made: what they noticed, who they assigned work to and what happened after they stepped in. An account of personally closing a deal with a major client leaves the main question unanswered: what did the rest of the team learn during that time?

It is easy for a business owner to assess a good account of a sale: the buyer, the difficult negotiations and the money received are easy to understand. Management is harder. The candidate’s team met its sales plan, but the salespeople have disappeared from the account: the candidate negotiated, secured approval and pushed the deal through themselves. You are hiring someone to take management off your hands, yet the interview is won by whoever most convincingly sells the idea that they are indispensable.

The form below brings the team’s work back into the conversation. You can copy it into your notes and fill it in for each candidate. To compare answers, choose one completed month from their experience and one employee they had to work with individually. This makes it harder to piece together a successful sale from one year and the results of an entirely different team.

Head of sales interview form

  • 1. The team when you joined. How many salespeople were there, where did clients come from, and how long did a sale take? Record: team composition, sources of deals, work that was already established when the candidate took over.
  • 2. Basis for the sales plan. How did you set the monthly sales plan and divide it among salespeople? Record: measure, initial data, calculation, a debatable assumption and who approved it.
  • 3. Decisions by week. When did it become clear in the chosen month that you were falling behind, and what did you change? Record: date, shortfall, the team’s new action and its result.
  • 4. Two months below the sales plan. How did you deal with a salesperson who had missed the sales plan for two months? Record: reason for the shortfall, help provided, time allowed to correct the mistake and the decision made.
  • 5. The next deal handled independently. What did the salesperson do on their own after you reviewed difficult negotiations? Record: previous mistake, the change in the next similar conversation, your involvement in it.
  • 6. Sales made personally by the head of sales. Which deals did you take over, and why? Record: reason for stepping in, work left to the salesperson and conditions for handing the client back to the salesperson.
  • 7. Early sign of a delay. How did you find out about a stalled deal before the end of the month? Record: a missed commitment, the source of the signal, your decision and the date of the action.
  • 8. Independent decisions. What did you decide without the business owner, and what did you bring to them? Record: permitted action, exception, proposed option and the owner’s response.
  • 9. A mistake by the head of sales. Which of your decisions did you have to reverse? Record: first sign of the mistake, when you reversed it, consequences for salespeople and clients.
  • 10. Evidence of experience. How can we retrace one of the decisions you have mentioned without disclosing client data? Record: an anonymised calculation, the sequence of events, someone involved who can confirm it.
  • 11. Requirements for starting. What do you need from us before you start work? Record: sales information, access, authority and decisions without which work will stop.
  • 12. The first month’s result. What will salespeople be doing independently by the end of the month, and what will confirm this? Record: starting point, expected change, evidence in their work, date for discussion.

Points 1–3 separate inherited sales from the candidate’s decisions. Points 4–6 show whether the results stay with the team after their help. Points 7–9 reveal how they act when there are delays or they make mistakes. The last three connect their account of the past with the work you intend to hand over. Below is how to interpret these notes and what details to substitute from your own team.

How should you assess a candidate’s answers on the form?

In an answer, look for a sequence of events and a change in how a salesperson works. Words such as “supervised”, “motivated” and “held sales meetings” leave the “decision” and “result” fields empty; ask them to go through one episode down to what a specific person did.

In your notes, distinguish between the candidate naming an action, naming an observable result and showing evidence. Do not add these marks up into an overall score. An excellent memory for figures does not make up for a lack of experience managing people. If, after follow-up questions, the candidate is still the only person selling in every answer, you are looking at a senior salesperson’s experience. For a leadership role, you will need separate evidence of how they get results from others.

How did the candidate set the sales plan and review it week by week?

Planning experience shows in the calculation: which sales make up the total and what the timing is based on. Points 1–3 of the form also need an example of a decision made before the month’s result was known. Dividing the total evenly by the number of salespeople does not explain this: one already has repeat buyers, while another was given a new contact list.

Suppose the sales plan is 10 million roubles, and repeat orders confirmed at the start of the month total 6 million. That leaves 4 million to come from other sales: subtract the repeat orders from the sales plan. By simple arithmetic, four salespeople would get a million each, but whether they can achieve that depends on their deals and the timing of purchases. Ask the candidate to explain what information they would request before dividing up these 4 million. The answer will immediately show whether they see the difference between dividing a sum and assigning achievable work.

For a weekly review, you need a different answer: which assumption stopped holding up and who had to act differently as a result. A buyer postponing payment, a shortage of new enquiries and a proposal delayed within the company call for different actions. The candidate should name the decision they made to address the cause they found. A report can keep telling salespeople the remaining amount too.

For your team, the measure used in the sales plan and the length of a sale will differ here. If money comes in instalments, the candidate must distinguish between the contract value and the payment for the month. If a sale takes longer than a month, the weekly review also covers progress on future deals: which approvals have been completed and what remains before the buyer makes a decision. One payment date cannot describe this work.

What did the salesperson retain after the head of sales helped?

The result of help from the head of sales shows in the employee’s next similar task. The fact that they negotiated together shows that help was given; independent action afterwards shows what the salesperson learnt. This is the basis for the notes in points 4–6.

If the sales plan has been missed for two months, first review the work available. Did the salesperson receive enough suitable enquiries? Did they have time to go through the full length of a deal? What kept recurring in their conversations? Then look at the specific help the head of sales gave and the change that followed. The answer “held a discussion, increased supervision” needs a follow-up: what exactly did the employee start doing differently, and where did the candidate see this?

Dismissal in itself does not show the quality of management either. Ask them to name the point when it no longer made sense to keep working with the person. If the head of sales set out the requirement in advance, gave the person a chance to meet it and saw them fail to meet it again, the decision is based on facts. If the only reason is “two months of missing the sales plan”, it remains unclear whether they investigated the causes.

It is normal to help with a major sale. The difference appears afterwards: who leads the next conversation, answers follow-up questions and agrees the next steps. When the buyer takes every subsequent question to the boss, the client has effectively changed salespeople. The candidate has added to their own client list; this has not yet taught the team to sell. That is why the form places questions about personal sales next to questions about the employee’s next independent deal.

When did the head of sales step in, and what did they decide themselves?

How independently a head of sales works shows in how they notice a delay and choose an action within their authority. In points 7–9, look for the event that led the candidate to step in: the buyer did not send the agreed data, the salesperson missed the deadline for a proposal, or the person responsible for approval on the client’s side changed.

Ask how the candidate found out. If the owner was always the first to find the delay and ask about it, the owner was responsible for detecting it early. The CRM system in this account merely stored information. In your team, the source of the signal must be tied to available data: tasks, correspondence and approval deadlines. The software’s name makes no difference.

The same precision is needed with independence. Redistributing enquiries among salespeople and changing payment terms are decisions at different levels. Your notes need both the actions they were allowed to take and the exceptions they took to the owner with their own proposal. If you have not yet defined the work to be handed over, the breakdown of the responsibilities of a head of sales will help: otherwise, you will be assessing candidates for different jobs.

The question about a reversed decision helps you see how someone handles uncomfortable facts. Look for the sign of a mistake they identified and the change in their actions. An account that blames only the market, the salespeople and the previous business owner gives you no material on the decisions made by the head of sales themselves.

What should you check in the first month after hiring?

In the first month after hiring, assess the sales plan calculation, decisions about employees who are falling behind, signals of delays and salespeople’s independent work. Before they start, agree these results with the candidate in points 10–12: what work they are taking on and what you will get by the end of the month.

Confirming previous experience does not require someone else’s client database. It is enough to reconstruct the logic of the calculation using anonymised data and, with the candidate’s consent, check their role in the episode described with their former supervisor. A general recommendation such as “a strong professional” is less useful than an answer about who noticed the delay and who chose the action.

At the start, record the state of deals already close to payment together with the new head of sales. Otherwise, money from previous agreements will count towards the assessment of their first month, while work with future buyers will go unnoticed. Do not subtract previous deals from the team’s result: note which decisions about them were made before the head of sales started and which came after.

At the end of the month, compare point 12 with the team’s actions. A salesperson handles similar negotiations independently; the head of sales spotted a delay; a decision to redistribute enquiries was made without a reminder from you. If all you have are new reports and deals closed personally by the head of sales, discuss the promised work in concrete terms, using the notes on the form. Their further development is covered separately: how to train a head of sales in the first few months.

What should you change in the form for your own sales team?

First, decide what work you are ready to accept from the new person. The form works both for an in-house head of sales candidate and for discussing a potential outsourced head of sales: in both cases, you are considering a head of sales.

If the business owner also wants to hand over the daily supervision of the head of sales themselves, one successful interview is not enough: someone must review their decisions and make sure corrections are made. RENTROP offers turnkey sales management for this task, so the business owner stops being the overall head of sales.

Change point 2, the basis for the sales plan, and point 12, the first month’s result, first. In point 2, specify your measure and the length of a sale: without them, an eloquent candidate can easily offer a calculation for someone else’s business. In point 12, name the work the team should do without you and without the new boss constantly stepping in. Then you use the interview to choose someone to take over specific work and, once they start, check that this is what they have delivered.