There are leads, but no sales. Marketing shows enquiries; salespeople reply: “They’re not a fit.” The business owner is caught between two reports that describe the same week as though they were about different companies.

The usual solution is to demand better enquiries from marketing. But first I would check something else: what exactly the sales team found out about the enquiries that have already come in.

The words “not a fit” can hide three different problems

Open the enquiries that salespeople closed as not a fit. Not the summary report by source, but the records, messages and conversations.

For each enquiry, you need an observable sign. The product does not suit the customer. They do not have the required volume, budget, timeframe or authority to make a decision. The company does not serve their industry or region. These are reasons that can be checked.

But other situations often sit alongside these: one attempt to call the customer failed; they asked to be sent information and did not reply; the salesperson heard “I’m just looking for now”; the conversation ended before anyone established what problem the customer wanted to solve. The outcome is the same: no sale. The reasons are different.

So the words “not a fit” mix together at least three different parts of the work:

  • marketing brought in someone the product really does not suit;
  • the sales team could not establish whether the person was a fit;
  • the person was a fit, but the salesperson did not guide them to the next decision.

As long as these groups sit in one row of the report, the dispute between marketing and sales cannot be resolved. The two sides have no shared factual basis.

A low conversion rate is not enough to prove poor lead quality

The conversion rate shows how the process ended. It does not show where it could have been changed.

If the record contains a confirmed sign that the enquiry is not a fit, the question goes back to the source: why did an enquiry like this come in, and can the promise, audience or filter be changed?

If there is no such sign, the first question is how the enquiry’s suitability was assessed. What did the salesperson ask? What did the customer answer? What fact justified closing the enquiry?

If the customer is a fit, but there is no agreed action after the conversation, the issue is how well the enquiry was handled. Buying different traffic will not fix a conversation that ends with “I’ll send you a presentation” without a date or a next step.

This is not a dispute about who is to blame. It is about separating three causes, each of which needs its own solution.

“But we cannot spend weeks chasing every enquiry”

Nor should you.

A weak enquiry does not need endless calls. If the customer clearly fails to meet the agreed criteria, the enquiry should be closed quickly. If there is no contact after a reasonable number of attempts, that is a separate outcome: “no contact”, not proof of a bad lead.

The point is not to keep every record open. The point is to avoid turning uncertainty into a convenient diagnosis.

“Not a fit” is a conclusion about the customer. “Could not get through” is a fact about the sales team’s work. “No next step agreed” is a fact about the conversation. When these things are described honestly, it becomes clear what needs to change.

A new website filter can make the report look better and the problem more costly

If you add fields, restrictions and questions before an enquiry can be submitted, some of the weak enquiries really will disappear. But you may also lose people who first needed the product explained to them or help putting what they wanted to achieve into words.

The filter should be changed after a review, not instead of one.

First, sales and marketing must agree on two lists. The first contains signs that an enquiry is definitely not a fit. The second contains facts the salesperson must establish before reaching that conclusion.

Then changing the form answers a specific question. For example: which sign can be identified before a conversation, without guessing and without losing a customer who is a fit? If there is no such sign, it is better not to add more to the form. The salesperson must check it.

You can settle the dispute with facts in a week

Take one source and all its enquiries from a short period that has already ended. Reconstruct five things for each enquiry:

  1. Whether there was contact with the person who submitted the enquiry.
  2. What problem they wanted to solve.
  3. Which agreed criterion made the enquiry suitable or unsuitable.
  4. What the salesperson suggested doing next.
  5. Which action the process stopped at.

There is no need to promise sales growth within a week. A different result is needed: reasons for closing enquiries are no longer based on guesswork.

If the same signs of a poor fit recur in one source, marketing has a precise basis for changing what comes in. If salespeople close enquiries before asking about the customer’s needs, the head of sales has a specific conversation to review. If customers who are a fit disappear after materials are sent, the next step needs to change, not the advertising.

After a week, there should also be a visible change in behaviour: when handling a new enquiry, the salesperson establishes the necessary facts, records an honest outcome and agrees on an action that can be checked. Otherwise, the review is just another table.

What the head of sales should do here

The head of sales does not choose the advertising budget for the business owner or promise to fix demand. Their job where the two sides meet is to stop them hiding different causes under one word.

They review conversations, agree with marketing on the signs of a suitable enquiry, change how salespeople work and return to new records to see whether the changes have been put into practice. Marketing is responsible for the quality of incoming enquiries and for ensuring there are enough of them, within agreed limits. Sales is responsible for assessing suitability and moving suitable opportunities forward. Decisions about the product, price and budget remain with the owner.

That is why turnkey sales management at RENTROP includes the daily work of a head of sales and contact with marketing about the quality of demand. The business development director checks whether the head of sales has turned the discrepancy into a solution and whether the team’s actions have changed, rather than looking at one side’s polished report.

Leads do not become bad when sales calls them bad. They become bad for the business when no one can show exactly where the opportunity ended.