Sales fell. The head of sales explains: clients went to competitors.

The report looks convincing: several deals were closed with “chose another supplier” as the reason. But the records do not explain what exactly the client chose, who was involved in the decision or after which conversation our position weakened.

The competitor may indeed have offered better terms. But before changing the price, script or presentation, I would check something else: the last decision the client was making when the sales team could still have influenced the outcome of the deal.

Without that fact, “went to competitors” is not the reason for losing. It is a label for the outcome.

The final rejection comes after the deal is actually lost

Open a deal that a salesperson closed after the client said: “We chose someone else.”

When did the client first say who they were comparing you with? Which selection criteria did they confirm? Who besides the person the salesperson spoke to influenced the decision? What did the client want to check before agreeing? What commitment did the salesperson make after the next conversation?

Often, a different sequence becomes clear between the first meeting and the rejection. The salesperson quickly sent a proposal. The client asked for time. A few days later, they received clarification on the price but did not discuss the differences. Then they stopped replying. Only at the end did they say they had reached an agreement with another company.

In this case, the deal was not lost at the moment of the final message. By then, the client had already reached their decision without the salesperson’s involvement.

This does not prove that the salesperson is weak. Perhaps the competitor really was a better match. But something else can already be seen from the record: the team learned about the choice when it was too late to change it.

“They’re cheaper” also needs checking

Price is a convenient explanation. It makes sense to the business owner, does not require reconstructing the negotiations and immediately suggests an action: offer a discount.

But the same words from a client can mean different situations.

In the first deal, the proposals are comparable, and the price difference really did decide the outcome.

In the second, the client did not see what they were paying more for because the salesperson listed the features but did not connect them to the problem the buyer needed to solve.

In the third, the price was discussed with someone who was gathering options, while their boss approved the criteria. The salesperson never made contact with the boss.

In the fourth, the client used price as a quick way to end the conversation because they had already chosen a supplier based on timing, risk or habit.

From the outside, all four deals get the same reason for closure. They need different responses: reconsider the commercial terms, change how the buyer’s problem is analysed, contact another person involved or check earlier whether the company has a real chance.

A discount offered to all four will fix only the first situation. In the others, it will lower the price but will not change the choice.

A reason for rejection reported by a salesperson is not yet a fact

After losing a deal, the salesperson needs to close the record. The list of reasons is usually short: too expensive, competitor, postponed, no longer relevant, stopped responding.

This list is convenient for reporting. It is not enough for the head of sales to make a decision.

A fact needs to answer at least three questions:

  • what decision the client was making;
  • what they looked at when comparing the options;
  • what action by the sales team could have changed the outcome, and whether it was taken.

If the salesperson did not ask these questions during the deal, it may sometimes be impossible to reconstruct the exact reason afterwards. That is also a result of the review. There is no need to fill the gap with a guess for the sake of a pretty chart.

An honest entry saying “reason not established: selection criteria were not identified” is more useful than a confident “competitor”. The first shows the work that needs to change. The second creates the impression that the team understood everything and could not have influenced the outcome.

Why a new presentation will not help on its own

After a series of losses, a company often starts reworking its materials. It adds a comparison, emphasises the advantages and trains salespeople to respond to objections.

This may be necessary. But first, it is worth understanding which decision the new material needs to change.

If the client could not see the difference between proposals, they will need a clear explanation of that difference in relation to their problem. If the salesperson was talking to the wrong person, the presentation will stay with the intermediary. If the criteria were identified after the proposal was sent, the order of the conversation needs to change first. If the company objectively falls short on a critical deadline, there is no way to make that same deadline more appealing through presentation.

A tool is useful only when the point at which to use it has been identified. Otherwise, the team will update the file and, a month later, bring back the same reasons for rejection.

A check to run for one week

Take a few of the most recent deals closed with “competitor” as the reason and review them with the head of sales. Do not ask the salesperson: “Why didn’t you sell?” This question almost guarantees a ready excuse.

Reconstruct the sequence:

  1. What problem was the client planning to solve with the purchase?
  2. Whose proposals were they comparing, and what criteria were they using?
  3. Who made the final decision, and was there contact with them?
  4. At what point did the first sign appear that our proposal was losing out?
  5. What did the salesperson do after that?
  6. What fact confirms the recorded reason for rejection?

Then choose one recurring problem. For example, salespeople send the proposal before finding out the criteria, or do not return to the comparison after a second participant appears.

The following week, the head of sales checks new, similar deals before the final rejection. The sign of change is simple: the salesperson records the criterion, the participant and the next step themselves before sending the proposal, and the head of sales sees the risk while they can still do something about it.

This check does not promise revenue in a week. It answers an earlier question: has the team started to understand how the client chooses, or does it still learn about the choice from a rejection message?

What needs to start working

The head of sales needs a review of buyers’ decisions, not a ranking of competitors.

They check not only closed deals but also active ones that have already reached a crossroads: the client has asked for a comparison, brought in another participant, changed the deadline, returned only to price or stopped doing what they had agreed to do. The head of sales uses these signals to choose an action before the loss, rather than an explanation afterwards.

Next, it is important to check whether the lessons are being applied. If one deal was reviewed, but in the next one the salesperson again sent a proposal without knowing the selection criteria, the review remained just a conversation. If the salesperson recognised a similar situation themselves and changed what they did without prompting, the team learned something.

It was this daily work that led us to the “turnkey sales management” model. At RENTROP, the head of sales manages deals and salespeople, the business development director checks the quality of the head of sales’ decisions, and AI helps find recurring reasons why deals stall by looking at data and communications. Decisions on the product, price, budget and commercial limits stay with the business owner.

But you should not start with RENTROP or a table of competitors. Start with the last deal you lost and find the moment when the client was still choosing.

The competitor takes the deal at the end. The sales team loses it earlier — when it stops influencing the client’s decision.