There are leads, but no sales. The CRM system shows that one salesperson received nine enquiries, the second ten and the third nine. The allocation looks fair. But one got returning clients, another complex calculations, and the third enquiries outside the company’s line of work.

I would not increase the advertising budget or blame the salespeople just yet. First, I would check what exactly the team calls an even allocation.

An equal number of enquiries does not automatically mean equal chances to sell.

Lead counts hide different work

Open the enquiries from the past week and remove the salespeople’s names. For each one, keep five details: what the client wants, whether the company’s offer suits them, whether they are new or existing, what decision needs to be made before the next step, and who in the team already knows how to handle deals like these.

The records will quickly stop looking identical.

One client knows exactly which configuration they need and asks how long it will take. The second still needs help choosing a solution. The third has brought a non-standard request that will need to be agreed with the production team. The fourth has returned for a repeat purchase and expects the company to remember previous agreements.

In the report, these are four leads. For the team, they are four different jobs.

If they are assigned in rotation, the queue will be balanced only by number. The workload, difficulty and chance of taking the conversation through to a decision will still differ.

“A strong salesperson will sell anything” is a convenient assumption, but it needs testing too

A strong salesperson really can work with different clients. But judging them on their overall conversion rate without considering the mix of enquiries is risky.

Imagine one salesperson receives repeat enquiries, while another gets initial enquiries without a clear task. The first produces invoices sooner. The second has more conversations end with “not the right client for us”. The final figures tell you who sold more, but they do not yet tell you who did the better job.

You need a record of actions. For a suitable lead, did the salesperson get in touch on time, clarify the task, agree the next step and see it through to a result? For an unsuitable one, did they quickly identify the characteristic that led to work on the enquiry being stopped, or spend several days pretending to work on it? For a complex deal, did they gather the necessary details about the terms and raise the issue with the head of sales, or simply postpone the task?

Only then can you distinguish between three causes: the salesperson cannot handle work that suits them; the enquiry went to the wrong person; the team treated an enquiry as a lead even though it does not meet its own selection criteria.

This is not a single problem. So there cannot be a single solution.

The obvious solution adds more enquiries to the same queue

When sales are low, marketing is asked to bring in more enquiries. This may be the right decision if the team has already analysed the enquiries coming in and really does not have enough suitable ones.

But if enquiries are assigned to whichever salesperson is free or in rotation, the new budget will not fix the allocation. It will add records to a queue where different deals are still treated as identical.

Training everyone in everything is not the first step either. Until it is clear which types of enquiries each person handles well and at which action things go wrong, the training programme will be built around general topics. Salespeople will be taught negotiation in general, even though one lacks product knowledge, another lacks the ability to assess whether an enquiry is suitable, and a third needs a decision from the head of sales on non-standard terms.

The problem is not that the enquiries were shared unfairly. The problem is that the head of sales distributes enquiries by number without managing the differences between deals.

The head of sales needs a testable rule, not a perfect algorithm

There is no need to build a complex scoring system straight away. For a week, it is enough to choose one clear characteristic that changes the salesperson’s work: a new or existing client, a standard or non-standard request, an established need or initial research.

The head of sales then does four things:

  1. Marks the chosen characteristic on each new enquiry before assigning a salesperson.
  2. Assigns the enquiry based not only on whose turn it is, but also on the salesperson’s ability to carry out the next necessary step.
  3. Checks the immediate result rather than the final sale: contact has been made, the client’s task is understood, the next step has been agreed or the reason for stopping has been confirmed.
  4. At the end of the week, compares similar enquiries and decides whether to keep the rule, change it or return to the usual queue.

You cannot promise sales growth within a week here. Some clients will still be unsuitable, some will decline because of price or terms, and some will postpone their decision. But after a week, you can already see whether fewer enquiries have stalled because they were assigned to the wrong person, and whether the reasons for rejection have become more specific.

If there is no difference, there is no need to defend an appealing assumption. Perhaps the allocation was working properly, and the limiting factor is response time, how enquiries are assessed, the offer or the number of suitable leads. In that case, the test has protected the advertising budget from a wrong diagnosis.

Where RENTROP fits in

In the “turnkey sales management” model, the head of sales is responsible every day for the progress of specific deals rather than a neat queue: who has been assigned the enquiry, why, what action is needed and what the result was. The business development director checks the head of sales’ decisions, while AI helps find recurring connections between the type of enquiry, the salesperson’s actions and the deal stalling.

The marketing budget, choice of channels, product and commercial limits remain decisions for the business owner. RENTROP is responsible for making sure the team does not ask for more enquiries until it has understood what it has already received.

Sharing equally is about the number of enquiries. Management starts with the question of who can take each one through to the next decision, and why.