Yes, a business owner can manage sales themselves — if they take on the daily management work: set tasks for people, insist they are done and work through what went wrong. Knowing the product and trusting a strong salesperson is not enough. When the owner only listens to the senior salesperson, some management duties remain unassigned, even though both are busy with sales.
We had a client — a trading company that imports goods itself and sells them through its own shops on online marketplaces. After the commercial director left, the owner decided to learn a little about the work and manage sales through the senior salesperson until a new head of sales was appointed. A young, very strong salesperson took the senior role. As a temporary solution, the choice made sense: he already knew the work and could sell.
But two years passed, and they still had not hired a new head of sales. The owner relied on the senior salesperson when making forecasts, but the salesperson could not set tasks for others and insist they were completed. The sales plans were missed. The company came to us when it was already in turmoil.
Later, the owner himself admitted that he had relied on someone too optimistic when making forecasts. This detail explains why I start talking about appointing the best salesperson by looking at the owner’s decision. There was a real basis for that trust. The trust simply went beyond what the employee had shown he could do.
His ability to sell did not answer the question about the others
I think it is a mistake to take someone’s own sales as proof that they can get their colleagues to do the work. In this case, the difference is plain: he could make sales himself, but could not set tasks and insist they were done. Age explains nothing here. The work that was left undone is enough to draw that conclusion.
When a salesperson is promoted, what you require of them changes. Before, their own actions showed what they had done to make a sale. Now you need to see what task another salesperson received from them, whether it was completed and what the person in charge did if that salesperson refused or failed to do it. The appointed senior salesperson’s own results do not answer these questions.
That creates an uncomfortable task for the owner: assessing a familiar, strong employee on work in which he has yet to prove himself. Appointing someone before they have proved themselves is acceptable. But then the owner takes on the job of teaching them and reviewing their first management decisions. If this work is not done, the word “senior” closes a question that should have stayed open: who makes sure the others do what they are asked?
In the trading company, the salesperson’s optimism became the basis for the owner’s forecasts. In my view, this is exactly what kept the temporary arrangement in place: they already relied on him when estimating future results, even though he could not manage the team. Acknowledging that limitation meant revising the owner’s own expectations too. Dismissing someone for being optimistic is too simple a conclusion to draw from this story. First, you need to stop expecting his confidence to prove that the whole sales department is doing its work.
The owner suggested meetings. Whether they happened was still unclear
There is a less noticeable detail in the same story. The owner had already suggested short daily meetings, but there was no certainty that they took place. There was no one to check whether the instruction was carried out. So the owner had given a useful instruction; it never became a consistent part of the work.
I would not start with a new schedule of sales meetings here. First, you need to find out what happened to the earlier instruction. Who was it given to? Who was supposed to hold the meeting? Who was supposed to notice that it had not happened? The answer determines what to do: assign someone to do it, give them time or hold them to account for failing to carry out the instruction. Another suggestion to hold meetings will leave the same gap.
The fact that a meeting took place does not settle the question either. If the senior salesperson only gathered updates for the owner, the owner will have to use those updates to manage the team. If he decided what the salespeople should do today and accepted their completed work by the set deadline, then there is something by which to assess his management work. Meeting minutes are useful only to the extent that they show this difference.
So I suggest checking the answer “I’ll manage it myself” against the owner’s calendar. Where is the time for assigning tasks to employees and reviewing how they were carried out? What other work has the owner put aside to make room for this? Gaps between other commitments are not enough if the department’s tasks require daily involvement. That is the cost of this way of managing, even when there is no separate head of sales salary.
A temporary arrangement needs an end date
I suggest formalising a temporary arrangement with a date for deciding what happens to it next. By that date, it should be clear whether the senior salesperson has learned to manage, whether the owner will continue doing it themselves or whether someone else is needed to do the job. The date is for the owner’s decision. There is no point promising that a suitable candidate will definitely be found by then.
The basis for this choice is already there in the current work. Take a task assigned by the senior salesperson whose deadline has passed. Who looked at the result and decided what to do next? If it was the owner again, the appointment has not yet relieved them of that duty. If the senior salesperson independently reviewed how the task was carried out, ask to see the decision they made. That gives you evidence of a skill that personal sales did not demonstrate.
There is a limit to this assessment: a lack of immediate growth does not prove that the senior salesperson has not learned to manage. First, you see how they work with people. Conversely, a successful month alone does not justify extending the temporary appointment: you need to understand whether the management work for which it was made is now being done. It is dangerous to lower the standards for this work because hiring is difficult — customers do not wait for a vacancy to be filled.
At RENTROP, an outsourced head of sales means that an appointed head of sales handles daily sales management and the requirements set for the team, including during a change of head of sales. If you are stuck in an “I’ll manage it myself through the senior salesperson” arrangement, at a free sales review we will look at which duties have stayed with you and who to pass them to.
A business owner has the right to manage sales themselves for as long as they see fit. But after two years, it is time to call that choice permanent and hold yourself to account for getting the work done: the word “temporary” does not do a head of sales’ daily work.