The costliest mistake is hiring the next salesperson without addressing the previous one's downtime: the company pays again to find and onboard someone, while the work remains blocked. Salesperson onboarding requires making the first calls together, reviewing difficulties every day and following a week-by-week plan that gives the employee more and more independent work. Their readiness should be judged by how they handle the deals available to them, separating the salesperson's mistakes from time spent waiting for replies within the company.
If a new hire was given a knowledge base and scripts, then left a couple of months later with no results, the explanation seems obvious: they were not up to the job. But during those months, they spent time both working and waiting for customers, terms of sale and an answer from their boss. In the company's costs, all of this counts as one employee's time. Those days failed to produce results for different reasons.
Below are seven mistakes: from the one that makes you pay for hiring all over again to unnecessary work with training materials.
Mistake 1. Replacing a new hire without examining their downtime
Before deciding to replace a salesperson, you need to understand where they could not manage the work available to them and where they were waiting for the company to act. A new employee will not fix an approval delay or the lack of a mentor: the next person will join the same queue.
From the outside, it all looks the same: the customer did not receive a proposal. But in one case, the salesperson did not clarify what the customer needed and does not know what to offer. In the other, they clarified the need and chose an option, but no one confirmed the current delivery times. A script will help with the first conversation. Another person must provide a confirmed delivery time.
When reviewing onboarding, the head of sales separates three reasons why work has stopped: the employee does not know what to do; knows but has not done it; or has requested a necessary decision and is waiting. The first is addressed through demonstration and practice, the second by requiring the task to be done, and the third by an answer from a specific person by a specific deadline. Without this, any shortfall is blamed on the quality of hiring.
Suppose that, out of 20 enquiries, eight have stalled because an internal approval is overdue, while the salesperson could have continued working on the remaining 12. Eight divided by 20 means 40% of enquiries are waiting for the company. The remaining twelve show how the employee works. For your own calculation, separate enquiries with a confirmed internal obstacle from those where the next action was up to the salesperson; the correspondence should show exactly what they requested and when.
Downtime remains a business expense and cannot be removed from the report. But the decision is now more precise: resolve the delay within the company, give the salesperson further training, or discuss replacing someone who is not doing work they have already learnt. Hiring again needs a more specific basis than a general impression of a bad month.
Mistake 2. Giving a new hire customers the team could not handle
The employee's first independent deals should let them apply the sales approach they have been shown. Using an old list of customers who turned the company down and contacts with no clear need tests the quality of the list, the offer and the new hire at the same time. Afterwards, you cannot separate the causes of failure.
It is understandable to save fresh enquiries for experienced salespeople: the company has already paid to attract them. But if a new salesperson only gets buyers whom no one could sell to before, the comparison of results is skewed from the start. After a start like that, it is easy to decide the candidate is weak and lose the person along with the time spent onboarding them.
For the first independent conversations, set aside some ordinary enquiries of the kind the employee has already reviewed with a mentor. Before handing them over, each enquiry should make clear what the buyer wants, what the team last did and what promise to the customer is due next. The team leader reviews any overdue promise first: the new hire should not first hear about it through a complaint.
Limit the number of enquiries handed over to what the team leader has time to support. Work on the current batch determines readiness for the next: the salesperson replies within the agreed time, keeps track of agreements and understands when help is needed. This lets the company limit the risk to customers and gives it a basis for increasing the workload.
If there are no suitable enquiries at all, the deadline for learning this part of the job moves back. There is no point blaming an employee for failing at a task when they were not given the material for it.
Mistake 3. Demanding that the full sales plan be met before deals are ready
The date by which a new hire should meet the sales plan must be based on when they start working with customers independently and how long a sale takes. The hiring date alone does not explain when a new hire should start bringing in money.
Suppose your completed deals take 30 days from the first conversation to payment. The new hire spent two weeks learning about the product and only received their first enquiries on the 15th. Requiring them to meet the full sales plan for revenue by the end of that month also makes them answer for the time when they had no customers of their own.
The cost of this mistake is choosing actions for the sake of the next report: asking colleagues for deals that are ready, offering a discount too early, or promising the buyer a date that suits them without approval. The owner gets money sooner but loses the ability to understand what the employee has learnt and what it cost to make the sale.
Use similar deals in your own sales team to determine when the first payments should arrive. Before then, assess what has already had time to happen: the customer has discussed their needs, received a suitable proposal and said how they will make the decision. When payment is due, compare expected receipts with actual receipts.
The salesperson needs to know the weekly requirements, the date they move to the normal sales plan and how their pay will be calculated during this period in advance. We discuss the pay scheme itself separately in “Motivating salespeople: a scheme and examples”. Here, the owner's task is to agree a transition in which the employee understands what work and results they are paid for from the first month.
Mistake 4. Planning onboarding around materials read
The onboarding plan should name the work the salesperson will learn each week and how they will demonstrate it. A list of sections studied is useful for the mentor but does not help decide which customers the new hire is ready to handle.
If the plan only lists the product, the CRM system and the script, the end of the week becomes a memory test. The employee repeats the rules, gets approval to proceed, then does not understand which rule to use in a conversation. Both their actions and the owner's expectations of the new employee have to be revised.
Here is what the first four weeks cover for a team where the salesperson takes an enquiry, clarifies the customer's needs, prepares a proposal and supports the buyer through their decision:
- First week: the team leader makes the first calls together with the new hire. The employee explains on their own who the product suits, asks questions about the customer's needs and records the agreement in CRM. The mentor shows where they had to step in and why.
- Second week: the new hire handles ordinary first conversations, chooses an offer and explains their choice. The team leader reviews difficulties every day, paying particular attention to promises the salesperson intends to make to the buyer.
- Third week: the salesperson independently follows up with customers at the agreed time, finds out what is stopping them from deciding and chooses the next action. The mentor checks where the employee needs the same prompt again.
- Fourth week: the team leader compares the quality of independent work, the volume of enquiries and the state of deals. Based on this, they increase the workload or leave a specific area for further work, with a date for another assessment.
The length of each stage depends on the product and the number of conversations the person has had a chance to work on. If deals take a long time, support for the customer will continue beyond the fourth week. Meanwhile, once the employee has learnt to handle initial enquiries, that work can already be handed over to them in full.
Each such transition requires a separate decision from the head of sales. Monday's arrival does not in itself give permission to handle more complex customers.
Mistake 5. Mistaking silence for independence
Fewer questions are a good sign only if the new hire is still working with customers. If questions disappear along with actions, the team leader loses the signal that there is a difficulty and only learns about it after the buyer says no or the employee leaves.
The phrase “everything is clear” says nothing about a specific deal. A short daily review is more useful: where the salesperson stopped today, what they decided on their own, where they waited for a reply and what became clearer after they received help. The head of sales chooses one difficulty, reviews it using a conversation from that day and checks how the employee handles the same action with the next customer.
The owner does not need to listen to all these conversations. The onboarding process should make three warning signs visible:
- Task deadlines are extended, but there has been no further contact with the customer. The team leader finds out what decision the salesperson is putting off.
- The same question comes back after an explanation. The head of sales checks what is missing: an understanding of the product, the authority to make a decision or the ability to handle a conversation.
- Help has been requested, but the buyer only gets an answer after the owner intervenes personally. Here, the delay is caused by the way help is organised within the team.
These are reasons to intervene in the work today. Waiting for a resignation letter to find out why is too costly: the conversation about leaving starts when the employee has already chosen their next step.
Mistake 6. Leaving mentoring for spare moments
Onboarding needs one person in charge, with dedicated time and the authority to change the new hire's workload. Making the best salesperson a mentor without reviewing their tasks puts training in the queue behind their own customers.
While they have few deals, they answer questions. By the end of the month, they have their own sales plan to meet, help is delayed, and the new hire waits or acts on guesswork. The company loses working hours from both people, even though the calendar makes onboarding look covered.
Calculate the time in advance. Suppose you allocate 45 minutes a day to joint conversations and reviewing the day. Over five working days, that is 225 minutes, or 3 hours 45 minutes. That is exactly the amount of time that must appear in the mentor's workload in place of other work. Adding a duty does not make their day longer.
If the head of sales also sells, the owner decides which of their customers or tasks are handed over to colleagues during onboarding. If there is no head of sales, someone must be appointed to lead it: a senior employee with the authority, or someone brought in to manage the work daily. HR arranges the employee's start and access; decisions about actions in live deals must stay with the person who leads sales.
When the owner has to provide help personally for every new hire, an outsourced head of sales may suit them: our head of sales works with salespeople and takes on daily sales management. This means the owner does not have to remain the main head of sales.
Mistake 7. Handing over the entire knowledge base on the first day
Starting materials are needed in the order the work will come up: what we sell, who the offer suits, how to conduct the first conversation and where to get help. A full document archive on the first day takes time away from skills needed on the very first call.
Split the knowledge base into what is essential to start and reference material for specific tasks. The starting section needs the product terms, limits on promises, the procedure for recording agreements and the names of people who resolve questions about price, timing and fulfilment. The employee can find details of an unusual configuration or a special paperwork procedure when the relevant request comes in.
Allow the materials to be used during work. If the salesperson quickly finds the term they need and explains it correctly to the customer, there is no reason to make them learn the whole document by heart. How to use what has been learnt in real conversations is covered in detail in “Sales team training: how to reinforce a skill at work”.
First, check for the mistake of replacing a person instead of resolving their downtime. The sign is a new hire being asked for results from customers for whom they requested help in time but never received an answer. Ask the team leader to show what happened to these requests before opening the next vacancy. If different new hires keep waiting at the same point, a new salesperson will simply start waiting all over again.