Suppose that after raw material prices rise, an item priced at 1 000 ₽ leaves the company 180 ₽ before fixed costs. The salesperson gives the permitted 5% discount — 130 ₽ remains. They have stayed within the limit. The company has given up 50 ₽ of the remaining 180 ₽, although permission for the discount was given when costs were different.

Demanding more sales from the team now is an odd way to start the conversation. First, you want to understand: who approved that 5% again after costs rose? If no one did, the salesperson is continuing to follow the old instruction. They can increase revenue while moving the company further away from the profit it needs. They will even receive a bonus for that result if their pay is based only on turnover.

At a meeting between our client, a confectionery manufacturer, and the head of sales and the business development director, a specialist showed how the cost of one ingredient affects product costs. During the conversation, someone said: “Even a change of five per cent is critical for us.” The suggestion was to identify the main ingredients, track their purchase costs and revise product prices on that basis.

That finding raises a question for sales management: what instruction will the salesperson receive when the calculation changes? A cost table does not, by itself, forbid the salesperson to do anything or give them permission to do anything.

More orders are not yet the answer to lost roubles

Advice to make up the lost profit through volume overlooks one figure: how much each additional item now brings in. Take a price of 1 000 ₽ and variable costs of 800 ₽. These are raw materials, packaging and other costs that depend on production and sales. That leaves 200 ₽ to run the company and make a profit. We calculate all amounts excluding VAT.

Suppose one ingredient costs 400 ₽ and rises in price by 5%. Costs per item will increase by 20 ₽, to 820 ₽. That gives us the 180 ₽ at the start of this discussion. A thousand items used to leave 200 000 ₽. Now even 1 100 items will leave only 198 000 ₽: 1 100 × 180. Revenue has increased by 10%, but with the same fixed costs, profit has fallen by 2 000 ₽.

The discount widens the gap. A price of 950 ₽ minus costs of 820 ₽ leaves 130 ₽. To get at least the 180 000 ₽ that a thousand items brought in after costs rose, without a discount, you would have to sell 1 385 units. We divide the required amount by what is left per item and round up. Additional costs for that level of production will increase the quantity needed.

If production requires no new fixed costs, every sale that leaves a positive amount adds money to the company. But an increase of a hundred items does not pay for a discount that requires another three hundred and eighty-five. Here, the head of sales needs to negotiate the order terms, rather than simply ask the salesperson to push the customer to place an order.

Who approves the discount after costs are recalculated

It is too early to blame the salesperson for lost profit. If they were given a price list and permission to discount by up to 5%, they are acting within their instructions. If new limits have already been communicated and they still sent the old price, that is a different breach. The timing shows the difference: when the new terms were introduced and when the proposal went to the buyer.

So news of a cost increase goes to more than just the person who calculates product costs. The head of sales receives a list of affected items and the new amount left from each one. Before the next proposal for these items, they find out whether the old discounts still apply. Without that decision, silence becomes permission to carry on.

For the figures above, a rule you can use looks like this. Suppose the owner has decided to keep at least 160 ₽ per item before fixed costs:

  • The price is 1 000 ₽; current variable costs are 820 ₽.
  • The salesperson can offer a discount of up to 20 ₽ per item without approval: the approved 160 ₽ remains.
  • If a 50 ₽ discount is requested, the head of sales submits the number of items, the 130 ₽ left from each and the costs of additional production for approval.

This is now a different conversation with the head of sales: they know which orders the team can close on its own and which decision to take to the owner. The owner chooses the acceptable earnings from an order; the head of sales makes sure salespeople negotiate within those terms. A decision to make an exception applies to the specified order. The next buyer does not receive the same discount just because it was approved once.

This arrangement also has a limit. When even the full price does not cover variable costs, the permitted discount will not fix anything. The owner will then need to change the price, what is included in the offer, or the costs. Increasing the sales plan will only increase the amount lost on these items.

The calculation is ready. What has changed for salespeople

The objection about doing someone else’s work is understandable here: is the head of sales really supposed to calculate ingredient costs? A specialist works out the recipe and the manufacturing cost. The head of sales is responsible for the next stage: the terms the salesperson took to the buyer after receiving the calculation. There is no need to hand over the accounting to them to do that.

But leaving every approval to the owner also makes no sense. Once given the 20 ₽ limit, the head of sales gives the team the right to work within it, removes the old discount from proposal templates and reviews requests that go beyond what is permitted. They keep orders already accepted separate from new ones: a change in internal figures does not, by itself, rewrite the agreement with the buyer.

The owner only needs to receive one new proposal from the head of sales after the recalculation, together with the basis for it. In our calculation, a price of 980 ₽ leaves 160 ₽; a price of 950 ₽ comes with a separate decision for that order. If the salesperson sent 950 ₽ without approval, the head of sales finds out why: an old template was still in use, the change had not reached them, or the employee bypassed a limit they knew about. Each cause needs its own correction before the next proposal.

This is where RENTROP works through “turnkey sales management”: we make sure the agreed limit is reflected in salespeople’s daily decisions and review departures from it. The owner regains the choice of terms, without having to personally approve every routine discount.

Advice to sell more becomes useful when the head of sales can explain on what terms that volume will bring in the money needed. Otherwise, the company pays for the increase in revenue by continuing to follow its own outdated permission to discount.